Being English used to be So easy. They were one of the most easily identified peoples on earth, recognized by their language, their manners, their clothes and the fact that they drank tea by the bucket-load. It is all so much more complicated now. When, occasionally, we come across someone whose stiff upper lip, sensible shoes or tweedy manner identifies them as English. By travelling into the past, we can discover the roots of the present anxiety of the English about themselves to the things that created that instantly recognizable ideal Englishman and Englishwoman who carried the flag across the world.Some, of these influences were relatively easy to spot.
Obviously the fact that they were born on an island rather living on a continental land mass had had an effect. They came from a country where Protestant reformation had put the church firmly in its place. They had inherited a deep belief in individual liberty. Once upon a time the English knew who they were. They were polite, unexcitable, reserved, prone to melancholy and had hot-water bottles instead of a sex life: how they reproduced was one of the mysteries of the western world. They were class-bound, hidebound and incapable of expressing their emotions. They did their duty.
Their most prized possession was a sense of honour. They were steadfast and trustworthy. The word of an English gentleman was as good as a bond sealed in blood. The most popular English films express the English people, in the immortal words, “we are not put on earth to enjoy ourselves”, and the second thing, the importance of a sense of duty – of sacrificing pleasures for-a greater good. One could assume about these people that they were decent and as industrious as was necessary to meet comparatively modest ambitions. They had a deeply held sense of their own rights, yet would proudly say they were “not much bothered” about politics.But they were not in any meaningful sense religious, The superficial changes had been vast: a lawless population had.
been turned into a law-abiding one; a country that enjoyed dog fights, bear-baiting and public hangings had become humanitarian and squeamish; general corruption in public life had been replaced by a high level of honesty. But, “what seems to have remained constant is a great resentment at being overlooked or controlled; a love of freedom: fortitude: a low interest in sexual activity compared with most neighboring societies: a strong belief in the value of education for the formation of character; onsideration and delicacy for the feelings of other people: and a very strong attachment to marriage and the institution of the family… ” The rest of the kingdom comforts itself with the chippy consolation that the English are the authors of their own nemesis and in a belief that the place is doomed. The English have characteristically taken this to heart because they have such a strong streak of natural gloominess. But this curiously, retiring, unintrospective, pessimistic people cannot continue as they are for much longer.They find themselves governed by a party whose organizing principles come from across the Atlantic and whose leadership caucus comes from north of the border.
The belief that something has rotted in England is widely held: a people cannot spend decades being told their civilization is in decline and not be affected by it. We might as well admit that the English are not an easy people to love. They have none of the charm of the Irish, the affability of the Welsh or the directness of the Scots. Even the quieter English possess that veneer of manners which conceals an infinite capacity for contempt.To be fair, they have a more attractive side to their character as well. They tend not to proselytize aggressively about their way of life any longer. And does any other society put such a premium upon having a sense of humour.
If you want to find out about what makes the English who they are, you quickly make two discoveries. First, that this offshore island has been sufficiently intriguing to attract quite awesome numbers of foreign visitors eager to share their impressions with the rest of the world: there are libraries filled with books of reminiscences and travellers’ tales.Second, very little at all has been written on the subject of English nationalism. Some of the reasons you can guess at quickly — no foreign occupation, no attempt to extinguish indigenous culture. So before the English submerge themselves, in gloom again, it is worth noticing that there is something positive about the fact that they have not devoted a lot of energy to discussing who they are.
It is a mark of self-confidence: the English have not spent a great deal of time defining themselves because they haven’t needed to. It seems something the English can no longer avoid.